In a recent episode on Eight FM, Hiredly’s VP of People & Culture, Joselyn, offered a candid look into how hiring decisions are made—especially when it comes to choosing between a highly skilled candidate and one with a great attitude.It’s a dilemma many hiring managers face: Do you pick the high-performer who might disrupt your team’s dynamics, or the coachable, positive team player who’s still learning the ropes?Let’s break down Joselyn’s insights from the conversation.“I’ll Always Choose Attitude Over Ability”Joselyn recalled asking her former boss early in her career: Would you hire someone who’s incredibly capable but has a poor attitude, or someone who’s average in skill but positive and team-oriented?Both then and now, her answer hasn’t changed—attitude matters more.“I prefer someone with average experience and ability, but who has a great attitude—because that affects your team’s morale and collaboration,” Joselyn explained.In short, soft skills like teamwork, openness to feedback, and humility can carry more weight than a flashy resume.👉 Learn more about soft skills vs. technical skills and which matter more in your job search.But Doesn’t Skill Matter?Yes, of course—skill and ability still matter. Joselyn clarified that when faced with a shortage of talent, companies might compromise by hiring someone with a less-than-ideal attitude if they urgently need the technical expertise.“It’s hard to find someone who matches 100% of what you’re looking for. Sometimes you’ll settle for 60–70%, especially when time or resources are tight.”But given the choice, most companies would rather train a motivated, team-friendly candidate than struggle with a toxic high-performer.👉 Related: What Employers Look at During Video InterviewsHow to Show You’re the Right HireIf you’re worried about not having enough experience, remember: your attitude and willingness to grow can be your biggest strengths.Here’s how to make a great impression:Show genuine curiosity and interest in the company and role.Highlight past experiences where you learned quickly or supported a team.Ask smart, thoughtful questions during your interview.Demonstrate emotional intelligence—empathy, accountability, and a positive mindset go a long way.👉 Prepare better: 6 Great Questions You Should Ask in a Job InterviewIf you’re starting your job search, take the Hiredly Work Personality Test to discover the roles that match your strengths. Want to connect with like-minded peers and grow your career network? Join Hiredly’s Young Talent Community. And when you’re ready to apply, head to Hiredly for the latest job opportunities across Malaysia. Listen to the full Instagram Reel here